I read Room by Emma Donoghue weeks ago and it is still haunting me –haunting in a good way. I had resisted this book initially despite the rave reviews. I’m not drawn to child narrators and the set up, a mother and child held in captivity for over 5 years in a room, seemed just horrific. On advice of good friends (always the best way to choose books) I picked it up AND could barely put it down. The inventive mother trying to create a good childhood for her little boy in a dreadful set of circumstances is amazing. The outcome is believable and moving. Most of all the weight and complexity of this story so beautifully told is still with me. There are many fine books I read, I enjoy, and I forget. This one will stay with me. DO put it on your list!
Thursday Thoughts
Welcome! I love talking about books with friends. Whether in organized book groups, over lunch, or a pot of tea, it is always a pleasure to discuss what we’re reading. Every Thursday I’ll share some thoughts with you and I hope you’ll join the conversation. Please tell me what books you are reading and pass along your recommendations.
Room by Emma Donoghue
March 14th, 2011 by Katharine DavisThe School of Essential Ingredients by Erica Bauermeister
February 20th, 2011 by Katharine DavisI read this novel several weeks ago and many of the characters have already gone out of my head–par for the course when I read one novel after another. Here is what I remember: The story revolves around a cooking school, Erica Bauermeister writes wonderfully about food, the overall feel of the novel was charming, and it was the perfect story to read after something dark or intellectually demanding. I recall turning the pages and savoring each scene along with the lovely illustrations. This book was a real pleasure, and to use a food analogy, this novel was like a perfect piece of Key Lime Pie-creamy, smooth, with just the right amount of sweetness, offering me the taste and texture of a delicious dessert.
The House on Fortune Street by Margot Livesey
February 10th, 2011 by Katharine DavisI read The House on Fortune Street recently for my book club and I loved it. Beautifully drawn characters, all muddling through lifes problems, seeking love, enduring the trials and complexity of family life and that wonderful Englishness–it’s all there. As a writer, I particularly enjoyed the structure of the novel. Instead of one linear narrative, we hear from several characters and each story enriches the others. This is a book about a longtime friendship and so much more.
Great House by Nicole Krauss
January 28th, 2011 by Katharine DavisSeveral serious reader friends recommended this novel to me so I put it on my list for Santa. Great House was a National Book Award finalist and came with high praise from the literary community. So, what did I think? The writing was beautiful and this book has lingered for me over several weeks. Claire Messud said that Krauss’s last novel, The History of Love” was “affecting” and I think that word fits this novel perfectly. The story drew me in entirely and I had to finish the novel. Did I love it? Not completely. Did I sometimes feel lost? Now and again, a little like reading with dark glasses, I had the feeling I wasn’t totally “getting it.” Was it a bit strange? Yes. It’s not a simple domestic drama. The threads were at time confusing and at the end I realized I would have to reread this novel to understand it more completely. Still, I had the impression I was part of something truly fine, something worthy, a novel with staying power.
I often go back to the world of painting when thinking about fiction. Nicole Krauss is not an impressionist read, something lovely, or an easy pleasure on the eyes. I think I’d compare her to a Rothko painting –dark, rich, mysterious, and mulit-layered. I know when I read this book again I will be duly rewarded.
Love and Summer by William Trevor
January 13th, 2011 by Katharine DavisOnward with the theme of old age! On a scrap of paper, or in some little notebook I had written down this title and quickly snatched up a copy when I saw it in paperback this fall. William Trevor is an older writer and his recently published collection of his many stories has received well deserved acclaim. Love and Summer is his most recent novel. His fiction is usually set in Ireland and for the first few pages of this novel I felt a comfortable familiarity-then, ah ha! I had already read this book. I slowly remembered the story, but I had to go on. Thus, I indulged in the pleasure of rereading a book and I wish I took the time to do this more.
Love and Summer is a captivating story, quiet, yet moving. Trevor’s writing reminds me of a Vermeer painting, exquisitly clear, all about light and beauty, simple, but deep. When I read a book for the second time I am able to take in the details and enjoy the story in a whole new way. I pay more attention to the setting, the nuances of character, and the language itself. All in all this is a lovely novel, the first time you read it, and the next.
Somewhere Towards the End by Diana Athill
January 7th, 2011 by Katharine DavisIn my last post I said that I enjoyed reading novels with older characters. This memoir by Diana Athill falls under that category for sure. Diana Athill is in her nineties and she reflects on this stage in life in this wonderful book. Athill was a book editor for many years and began writing later in her career. Her writing is sharp and poignant and as she tells about her life you feel like you are sitting down with a good friend having an honest and heartfelt conversation. I look forward to reading her earlier work, four other memoirs and one novel.
The Widower’s Tale by Julia Glass
December 30th, 2010 by Katharine DavisThe Three Junes is still my favorite of Julia Glass’s novels but The Widower’s Tale would have to follow close behind. Glass tackles the question of privilege, parenting, love later in life, relatiohships, and the ususal human dramas that draw us to read novels. This was one of those novels I enjoyed picking up, an interesting world, complicated characters, and just enough tension to keep me wanting to turn the pages and see what’s coming next. Now and again, I felt there was a little too much going on, but in the end I liked the way she brought it all together. I especially liked the oldest character, Percy Darling. I enjoy books with older characters and I wish more writers tackled issues of mature people- okay – old age!
Major Pettigrew’s Last Stand by Helen Simonson
December 23rd, 2010 by Katharine DavisI bought this novel last summer and only just got to it a few days ago. The bottom line is that the book is pure pleasure. It was predictable from the first page- even the cover illustrated that it was a love story, a love story with a happy ending. But, predictable in the best way- like a gorgeous piece of cake that you eat slowly, knowing that it was lovingly made with only the best ingredients, a piece of cake that does not disappoint. Do not miss this novel –a perfect mixuture of sweetness, charm, social strife, family difficulties, and loads of humor- that wonderful wry British humor. I salute Helen Simonson on a terrific debut and I can see why she broke out of the pack! This novel is fresh and a joy to read!
Where the God of Love Hangs Out by Amy Bloom
December 20th, 2010 by Katharine DavisWe are in the midst of the busy holiday season and maybe a good time to turn to a collection of stories when reading time is more limited. I find it a great pleasure to to finish reading a story in one sitting and come away with some kind of feeling or truth that stays with me. Amy Bloom is a fabulous writer and these stories will keep you thinking. Her characters are real and emotionally complex. The theme is love in all its many forms. These stories are poignant and at times heart wrenching. The stories are connected, though each stands alone. Just when you think -oh that was amazing, so real, so intense –you turn the page and the same characters are there, pulling you in once again. An excellent collection!
By Nightfall by Michael Cunningham
December 2nd, 2010 by Katharine DavisSome readers want to read novels with likeable characters. I agree it’s satisfying to enter a story, care deeply about the outcome for this or that person, even cheer for the protagonist. The married couple in By Nightfall are not particularly likeable people. I can imagine many readers describing them as self-absorbed and spoiled. They work in New York, have jobs in the arts, and have precious lives complete with a loft in SoHo. But Cunningham is a master of language. He has an astute sensibility, a way of creating interior lives with the power and lyricism comparable to Virginia Woolf, the writer he emulted so brilliantly in his novel, The Hours. Peter, the main character, is on the cusp of ruining his life, his marriage, his family. I certainly did not want to cheer for him. However, the underlying angst, the deeply psychological struggle, and the odd pull of sexuality, made this a riveting book. This novel has a haunting quality and like a fine foreign film, the images will linger long after the closing scenes.